Fuxing’s share price dipped 12% after good results

Fuxing announced its 4QFY10 results on 1 Mar 11, after trading hours. Despite a good set of results, Fuxing has slid 12% from $0.170 on 1 Mar 11 to $0.150 on 11 Mar 11 on lower than average volumes (except for one day – 7 Mar 11). So what constitutes the fall in the share price?
Some potential “reasons” to the drop in share price
Besides the poor market sentiment relating to S chips (especially after the audit issues on China Hongxing and Hongwei etc), I shall hazard some guesses to the reasons why there is a drop in Fuxing’s share price.
Firstly, Fuxing has reduced its target dividend payout ratio from not less than 40% to not less than 25% in FY11 and beyond. This may affect some investors who have previously bought Fuxing potentially for high expected dividend yields. I have put in a table to illustrate the potential impact on the change in dividend payout ratios to the dividend per share to the investors.
Table 1: Illustration of how dividend payout ratios affect dividend per share
Dividend Payout Ratio
**FY11F Earnings Per Share (“EPS”) (RMB cents)
Dividend Per Share (“DPS”)
(RMB cents)

Source: Ernest’s calculations; analyst reports
*Small differences in the figures above are due to rounding errors
**For the FY11F EPS, I have used the average of DMG and NRA estimates
With reference to Table 1 above, based on the average EPS estimate and a minimum 40% dividend payout, Fuxing is likely to pay at least a DPS of RMB5.3 cents for FY11F. However, if the company undertakes a dividend payout ratio of 25%, FY11F DPS would drop to RMB3.3cents. This is how dividend payout ratio affects the final quantum of dividends paid out to shareholders.
Secondly, some investors are concerned with the rising working capital requirements from the advances / partial deposits being made to suppliers which consequently results in a negative operating cash flow for the company. Fuxing has explained that they made such advances / partial deposits so as to secure a guaranteed stream of raw materials at competitive prices. They elaborated that this practice of advance payment follows the past practice where they have made prepayments of RMB81.8m; RMB240.2m and RMB283.9m in FY2009, FY2008 and FY2007 respectively. (Refer to Fuxing’s press release on 8 Mar 2011)
Management further assures that they have assessed the credit risk from such arrangements to be low and manageable.
After the results, I managed to catch up with Choon Kong, Fuxing’s CFO and Jennie, Fuxing’s Investor Relations (“Management”) for a 1-1 meeting. Below is a summary of the pertinent points discussed.
Acquisitions of the three target companies to be completed in early 2QFY11
Fuxing has obtained the shareholders’ approval through a special general meeting on 4 March. Barring any unforeseen circumstances, they target to complete the acquisition by early 2QFY11 whereby earnings from the three target companies would be consolidated into Fuxing’s 2QFY11 financials and beyond.
On the prowl for more acquisitions à in zipper companies.
According to management, they are on the lookout for acquisitions in zipper companies. Nevertheless, as this is just on the drawing board, they do not have details yet. Pertaining to my concern that they may be expanding too quickly, especially since the three acquisitions have not been finalized and integrated yet, management is quick to allay concerns. 
Management emphasised that there is unlikely to be integration issues for the three acquisitions as the three target companies would still be mainly managed by the incumbent management and as a stand alone business. Furthermore, Fuxing has worked with these three companies before and thus management understands these target companies and believes that operational synergies can be obtained by acquiring them.
More details on the progress of Super Durable Zippers (“SDZ”) unveiled
As of now, all the 100 SDZ machines have been installed. They have been operating the machines to do sampling tests which were sent to clients for assessment. Their potential clients are manufacturers of ladies’ boots and high end travel. Fuxing would be ramping up their marketing efforts for the SDZ. However, the response and the contribution from these SDZ are not known with certainty yet.
Tax rebate pending approval from the authorities
Fuxing obtains the New and High Technology Enterprise which allows its subsidiary to be taxed at a preferential rate of 15% for the next three years. Based on my understanding from management, management’s request for a tax rebate is pending approval from the authorities. Currently, they are unable to ascertain their chances of the tax rebate being approved. Nevertheless, management added that the organic growth of Fuxing’s existing operations and the profit contribution from the three target companies would constitute good growth for the company’s earnings even without the tax rebates.
In view of the weak share price and good growth prospects, would management consider share buybacks?
Management is open to share buybacks but this depends on the share price as well as any other competing uses of their cash. Nevertheless, as they have already obtained the shareholders’ approval last April’s AGM for a renewal of share purchase mandate, they are able to do so for now before their next request for the renewal of share purchase mandate in the upcoming AGM.

(I have emphasized to management to seriously consider this aspect as buying back company’s shares is a bullish and reassuring signal to existing and potential shareholders on the company’s confidence in their own prospects.)
Positive full year contribution from Shanghai, Qingdao plants in FY2011
In line with the guidance given in 3QFY10 briefing, management is confident that Shanghai and Qingdao plants would have a positive full year contribution from Shanghai and Qingdao plants in FY2011 as they reported improving and encouraging sales in 2HFY10.

Challenges: Rising labour and raw material cost
Raw material costs constituted about 75% of its FY10 Cost of Goods Sold (“COGS”). To reduce the impact of rising raw material costs, management made advances / partial deposits to suppliers so as to secure a guaranteed stream of raw materials at competitive prices.
Labour costs have also been rising. Management recently hiked its wages by about 10% so as to retain their workers. (This seems to be effective as 95% of their workers came back to work after Chinese New Year). They are also building dormitories to improve working conditions so as to attract and retain workers. It is noteworthy that labour costs only contributed about 11% of FY10 COGS.
Lastly, management believes that as long as the rising labour and raw material costs increase gradually, they are able to pass the rising costs to customers. This is because firstly, zippers’ costs are a very small percentage of the finished products, thus this would not have a serious impact to their customers. Secondly, if Fuxing (2nd largest in China in terms of production capacity) has to raise prices, it is likely that other zipper makers would be raising theirs as well. Thus, it is likely that customers would continue to buy from Fuxing.
Conclusion – remains in my suggested list, despite the drop in share price
With reference to Table 2 below, based on Bloomberg, Fuxing’s FY11F PE is around 5.7x which is lower than the 29.3x FY11F PE of its next competitor Fujian SBS (the largest in China).
Choon Kong, together with Mr Hong Qingliang, chairman and CEO of Fuxing have been actively meeting fund managers, analysts, shareholders for the week ended 4 Mar. If Fuxing can successfully consolidate the three target companies from 2QFY10 onwards and the ramping up of its SDZ business, it is only time when it starts to attract the attention of the investment community. (Refer to Chart 1 for analysts’ target price on Fuxing)
Table 2: Comparison of Fuxing vis-à-vis its peers
Short Name
Lcl Cur
Last Px
Analyst TP
Adj Mkt Cap (S$m)
ROE (%)
Fuxing China Grp
Cmz Holdings Ltd
Fujian Sbs Zip-A
Zhejiang Weixi-A
Max Zipper Co L
Average ex Fuxing

Source: Bloomberg (as of 11 Mar 11)

Chart 1: Analysts’ target price on Fuxing
Source: Bloomberg (11 Mar 11)
This is an amended version which I have sent out to clients recently.
The information contained herein is the writer’s personal opinion and is provided to you for information only and is not intended to or nor will it create/induce the creation of any binding legal relations. The information or opinions provided herein do not constitute an investment advice, an offer or solicitation to subscribe for, purchase or sell the investment product(s) mentioned herein. It does not have any regard to your specific investment objectives, financial situation and any of your particular needs. Accordingly, no warranty whatsoever is given and no liability whatsoever is accepted for any loss arising whether directly or indirectly as a result of this information. Investments are subject to investment risks including possible loss of the principal amount invested. The value of the product and the income from them may fall as well as rise. You may wish to seek advice from an independent financial adviser before making a commitment to purchase or invest in the investment product(s) mentioned herein. In the event that you choose not to do so, you should consider whether the investment product(s) mentioned herein are suitable for you. The writer will not, in any event, be liable to you for any direct/indirect or any other damages of any kind arising from or in connection with your reliance on any information in and/or materials appended herein. The information and/or materials are provided “as is” without warranty of any kind, either express or implied.  In particular, no warranty regarding accuracy or fitness for a purpose is given in connection with such information and materials.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *